3rd Grade Writing Report Card Comments
3rd Grade Writing Report Card Comments for teachers — ready to copy and paste. Includes comments for excelling, on-track, and struggling students.
Third grade is a turning point in writing development—students move from "learning to write" to "writing to learn." The Common Core standards expect third graders to produce organized opinion pieces with reasons, informative texts with facts and definitions, and narratives with dialogue, descriptions, and a clear sequence of events. Students should begin planning their writing, revising for clarity and detail, and editing for conventions including correct use of commas, quotation marks, and possessives. Comments should reflect both the content and craft of a student's writing, noting specific strengths and targeted areas for improvement.
What 3rd grade students should know in writing
- Write opinion pieces that introduce a topic, state an opinion, provide reasons that support the opinion, use linking words, and provide a concluding statement
- Write informative/explanatory texts that introduce a topic, group related information together, develop the topic with facts and details, and provide a concluding statement
- Write narratives that establish a situation, introduce characters, use dialogue and descriptions, organize events in a logical sequence, use temporal words, and provide a sense of closure
- Plan writing by brainstorming, using graphic organizers, or creating outlines before drafting
- Revise and edit writing with guidance, strengthening pieces by adding details, clarifying ideas, and correcting errors
- Use correct capitalization, punctuation (including commas in addresses and dialogue), and spelling of grade-level words
- Use quotation marks correctly in dialogue
- Form and use regular and irregular plural nouns, abstract nouns, and possessives
- Write in complete sentences with subject-verb agreement, varying sentence structure for clarity and interest
- Use technology to produce and publish writing, including keyboarding skills
Comments for excelling students
[Student] is a talented writer who produces well-organized, multi-paragraph pieces across all genres. He uses linking words like "because," "therefore," and "for example" to connect his ideas, and his opinion pieces include clearly stated positions with multiple supporting reasons. His command of writing conventions—including dialogue punctuation and possessives—is well above grade level.
[Student] writes vivid narratives that captivate her readers with rich descriptions, realistic dialogue, and carefully sequenced events. She demonstrates a strong sense of voice and audience, adjusting her tone and word choice depending on the purpose of her writing. Her willingness to revise multiple drafts results in polished, engaging final pieces.
[Student] excels at informative writing and can clearly explain complex topics using facts, definitions, and details organized into logical paragraphs. He uses text features like headings and bold vocabulary words to enhance his writing, and his concluding statements effectively summarize the key points. His research skills are developing impressively for a third grader.
[Student] approaches the writing process with maturity and independence. She consistently plans her pieces using graphic organizers, writes detailed first drafts, and revises thoughtfully by adding descriptive language and eliminating unnecessary information. Her editing skills are strong—she catches most spelling, capitalization, and punctuation errors on her own.
[Student] demonstrates exceptional growth as a writer this year. He experiments with advanced techniques such as varying sentence length for effect, using figurative language, and crafting strong opening hooks. His writing portfolio shows tremendous progress from September to now, and his confidence as a writer continues to grow with each assignment.
Comments for on-track students
[Student] is developing her writing skills and can produce organized pieces in all three genres with teacher support. She includes a topic sentence, supporting details, and a concluding sentence in her paragraphs, though she sometimes needs reminders to elaborate on her ideas with specific examples. Continued practice with adding details will strengthen her writing.
[Student] writes narratives that include a clear beginning, middle, and end with sequenced events. He is learning to incorporate dialogue and is becoming more comfortable using quotation marks correctly. His stories would benefit from more descriptive language to help readers picture the scenes he creates.
[Student] is making steady progress with opinion writing and can state her position and provide one or two supporting reasons. She is learning to use linking words to connect her ideas and is developing her ability to write a strong concluding statement. Practicing persuasive writing at home—such as writing letters about topics she cares about—would reinforce these skills.
[Student] participates actively in the writing process and is developing his revision and editing skills. He can identify areas where his writing needs more detail and is learning to use a checklist to catch spelling and punctuation errors. His spelling of grade-level words is improving, and continued practice with word study at home will support this growth.
[Student] approaches writing tasks with effort and is building fluency as a writer. She can compose complete paragraphs independently and is learning to vary her sentence structure for interest. Encouraging her to read widely—noticing how authors craft their sentences and organize their ideas—will help her develop her own writing style.
Comments for struggling students
[Student] finds it challenging to organize his thoughts into coherent paragraphs and often writes pieces that lack a clear structure. He tends to jump between ideas without using transitions or logical sequencing. Working with graphic organizers before writing and practicing the "tell me your plan" strategy—where he verbally rehearses his piece before writing—would help him develop organizational skills.
[Student] struggles with writing conventions, including capitalization, punctuation, and spelling, which makes her writing difficult to read. She often omits periods and capital letters and has not yet mastered quotation marks or comma usage. Focused, daily practice on one convention at a time—starting with end punctuation and capital letters—would help build these foundational skills.
[Student] has difficulty generating ideas and often stares at a blank page for extended periods before beginning to write. He produces very little text during writing time and frequently says he does not know what to write about. Providing him with topic choices, sentence starters, and opportunities to talk about his ideas before writing would help him get started more easily.
[Student] writes brief, underdeveloped pieces that rarely include supporting details, reasons, or descriptions. She can write complete sentences but has difficulty expanding them into full paragraphs. Practicing the "add more" strategy at home—writing one sentence and then asking "What else can I tell the reader?"—would help her build stamina and depth in her writing.
[Student] is significantly below grade level in writing and continues to need intensive, one-on-one support to produce written work. He struggles with sentence structure, spelling, and handwriting, which compound to make writing a frustrating experience. We recommend meeting to discuss targeted intervention strategies and whether an evaluation for learning support services would help address his needs.
Was this page helpful?
Get 50 free report card comments
Ready-to-use comments for every student type — delivered to your inbox as a printable PDF.